As an insolvency practitioner, our duty is to look at all options when a charity is struggling financially. Sometimes people assume our only role is to close the charity, but in fact, we look at all options to see if there is a way for the organisation to survive. Sometimes that is possible, and sometimes we need to face the unfortunate truth that the charity is not financially viable and needs to go the insolvency route. When that happens, it’s vital that we look at several key issues as soon as possible so that everything is legal and follows the correct process.
One of the most complex of these is restricted funds. We are happy to advise on other areas, but for no,w let’s look at how restricted funds can and can’t be used.
The first thing to look at is what are, and are not, restricted funds. For convenience, let’s just focus on what restricted funds are firs,t and then we can go on to look at what you can and can’t do with them.
Restricted funds are donations or grants given to a charity with specific conditions attached. These restrictions mean the funds can only be used for a particular purpose or project, as outlined by the donor or funding body.
So, what that means in plain English is that these particular funds are ringfenced and can only be used for the purpose they were meant for.
Some common examples of the kind of donations that create restricted funds could include:
These are just a few examples, but they give a good idea of the kind of charitable aims surrounding restricted funds.
Once they are designated as being for a purpose, restricted funds cannot be used for any other purpose. That means they must:
The charity doesn’t usually need to go such lengths as keeping separate bank accounts or similar, but they must be able to account for the funds. So, records must be totally transparent about how they are used, where they are held, and they must also be clearly and accurately identified in the charity’s accounts.
The temptation here is to give an emphatic ‘no’ to using restricted funds for any general purposes. In the letter of the law, this is absolutely the case. Restricted funds are ringfenced for a specific use. However, as always, things are not quite as clear-cut as we would all like.
The first thing to say is that anyone involved with a charity that is using restricted funds for any purpose that raises a question about ‘legitimate use’ needs to be very careful before they proceed. Check fully and take expert advice about whether the use you intend to put them to will be allowable. If you don’t confirm, and it turns out later that you misused restricted funds, you could find yourself in some very hot water.
That said, (and after repeating our usual guidance that every situation is different and you should always seek professional advice when you need it), here are a few thoughts that may help.
Restricted funds will generally fall into two broad categories.
There is sometimes a slightly grey area around what is covered by the restriction on the use of the funds, though. Unclear or non-specific descriptions can be difficult to deal with and may allow for wider use. Again, it is vital to check how you are interpreting the donor's wishes.
The short answer is, technically, no!
Restricted funds are, by their very nature, restricted to the purpose for which they were donated. Therefore, in practice, they are often not available to help pay general debts, no matter what the circumstances.
What that means in practical terms is that if a UK charity becomes insolvent (unable to pay its general debts), the trustees cannot automatically use restricted funds to cover the charity’s liabilities. Restricted funds remain protected and ring-fenced, and using them improperly could constitute a breach of trust and charity law.
However, in some circumstances, as we mentioned earlier, it could be possible to change their use. You could, for example, ask the original donors to allow redirection of the funds, or it may be that the description of how they are to be used has some leeway in it.
Alternatively, legal permission could, in theory at least, be sought to lift or alter the restrictions due to exceptional circumstances. However, typically this will only be granted if the original charitable purpose is no longer possible or practicable and no other options are available that meet the wishes of the donor. A good example of when this is more likely to be acceptable legally is if the funds were intended for something that is difficult to define or no longer exists in the same form. Times change, and the use of the funds may well need to change with them. If that can be proven, then the charity could look to a change of purpose. However, it will need to be a solid, legitimate reason.
Restricted funds in UK charities are protected and not freely accessible for any other purpose, and that could include paying debts during insolvency. Trustees must respect the original purpose and seek appropriate approval before attempting to redirect restricted funds for insolvency purposes.
Misusing restricted funds in a charity during insolvency, or for any other reason, is considered a serious breach of trust and charity law. It can result in significant consequences for the trustees or the charity officers involved, including legal action against them, resulting in criminal charges or becoming personally liable to repay the funds.
Over the years, we have dealt with many charities with financial issues, and one of the least understood areas is ... more
Remember when unpredictable market conditions were rare occurrences? Don’t misunderstand me, the ... more
A secure and reliable supply chain is fundamental to a business’s survival. Whether you are a ... more
The purpose of Debt Awareness Week is to encourage open conversations about financial struggles and provide ... more
Charities and other third sector organisations are just as susceptible to insolvency as private companies. ... more
With what looks like a very difficult time ahead, reviewing your credit control now could be the difference between ... more
When a long-standing business is closed under an MVL, retirement is far and away the most common reason. Closing ... more
In October last year, a budget was delivered that will have repercussions for business throughout the coming year. ... more
When you are faced with business disagreements over payments, contracts, or other areas such as the management of ... more
Sadly, organisations that come under the Co-operative and Community Benefit Societies Act 2014, are just as prone ... more
Capital Gains Tax and Entrepreneurs Relief – A change as we predicted. In our previous blog , we looked ... more
The Autumn budget wasn't exactly a friendly one for SMEs. Whether it will lead to more insolvencies and financial ... more
There was a relatively large rise in the number of Joint and Several Liability (JSL) Notices in the last year. ... more
According to recent data from the Insolvency Service, the construction sector remains one of the industry areas ... more
According to Charity Debt Justice, around 6.7 million people in the UK are considered to be in financial ... more
In the run-up to the election, the current government made some very clear promises that could have quite an effect ... more
There is always bound to be a question about when it is the right time to push the button on a member's Voluntary ... more
When you are responsible for a business that is facing insolvency, or potentially facing personal financial issues ... more
Here we go again. The election is ramping up and the media are dissecting every statement and promise in search of ... more
What happened between John Barnes Media Limited and HMRC? According to the Insolvency Service news, John Barnes ... more
One of the actions taken during an insolvency is for the company assets to be sold to help pay debts. This is ... more
The politics of a budget are not really in our area of interest, to be honest. The motivations behind decisions ... more
There have been a couple of dramatic looking statistics about company closures and recessive economies recently. ... more
HMRC have issued an update to how Members Voluntary Liquidations (MVLs) are processed. The change is quite a shift ... more
According to the Office of National Statistics (ONS), retail sales fell 3.2% in December 2023. With a harsh outlook ... more
Christmas is around the corner, and the last bell is about to ring for 2023, so it’s a good time to sit back ... more
We are all aware that a business can become insolvent - but what about the over 168,000 charities currently ... more
This year the Autumn statement was a bit of a mixed bag for business and individuals. National insurance giveaways ... more
Do personal finances impact business finances? When you run a business, one of the first things any of your ... more
The jump in insolvencies in September follows a similar increase in August. However, there was a drop in July. So ... more
Bankruptcy and insolvency are not the same thing, but they are closely related. Maybe that is why they are ... more
Economic sunshine and showers. We have gotten used to having a more Mediterranean style summer in the last few ... more
It often still comes as a surprise to directors when they learn that they can claim redundancy. If you meet the ... more
Does being local matter? After all, insolvency is about logic and process, isn’t it? To answer that ... more
Warning: Insolvency Service ... more
The recent budget may well have not been much of a shake up for the economy but it did contain some things to need ... more
Can I be disqualified as a director over a Bounce Back Loan? Let’s deal with the big questions first. In ... more
What happened with Capital Gains Tax and MVLs? To be clear from the outset if you are thinking of closing your ... more
A year of financial white water 2022 started with a lot of hope, didn’t it? By the end of January Covid ... more
What’s going on in Hospitality? You cannot help but feel for pubs, restaurants, and other venues. It must ... more
It isn’t unusual that a director of a company will have an outstanding director’s loan account. If that ... more
What makes a good Insolvency Practitioner? There are some fundamental skills and experience that should really ... more
What does ‘intent to appoint administrators’ mean? If you have been keeping up with the news ... more
Green, amber, and red lights of insolvency If we were to make a list of things that directors usually tell us ... more
How bad are things for business? You can’t help but notice that the economic news is pretty grim at the ... more
Personal guarantees can be a problem when a business becomes insolvent, and directors are often concerned about ... more
What happened to the insolvency crisis? Back in what now feels like aeons ago during 2021, there were rumblings ... more
The cost of business crisis. Without knowing your expenditure, it is almost impossible to make a sound judgement ... more
The importance of honesty. There is nothing the press likes more than a celebrity scandal and former Wimbledon ... more
You have probably seen various stories in the press about Directors of businesses being caught out because they ... more
Why do people consider a Members Voluntary Liquidation? Unlike insolvency, which is driven purely by financial ... more
When the insolvency legislation was temporarily changed during the pandemic, I suspect there was a widespread sigh ... more
I heard a wonderful phrase to describe the current situation the other day. Someone said they would be glad when ... more
If you run a business and don’t currently have cashflow planning at the top of your agenda, you probably ... more
Yes, for those of you that watched ‘Game of Thrones’ you will appreciate that this is the threat of bad ... more
As you will appreciate, during the pandemic HMRC has been very busy dealing with the various support schemes, ... more
Companies in financial distress as a result of the pandemic have been protected from creditor action since last ... more
When a Company fails it is quite common that directors are excused of Wrongful or Insolvent trading. Wrongful ... more
This is the fourth time I have written about the Government extensions of the insolvency provisions brought in ... more
I the first of these BBL articles we looked at your options if you are struggling to pay your Bounce Back Loan ... more
Bounce Back Loans are becoming a big problem area and we may only be scratching the surface of the impact they may ... more
The Government has announced a new scheme to help individuals with debt problems. The scheme is described as ... more
First of all, it is fair to say this blog is very technical and probably more for our professional contacts, so if ... more
The Insolvency Service produces monthly figures for both corporate and personal insolvencies and as mentioned ... more
The answer to the question ‘when is a good time to close your solvent business’ is never an easy one. ... more
Why Groundhog Day you ask? Over the last 12 months, I have posted about various Governments measures brought in ... more
Believe it or not, it has been almost 12 months since businesses in the UK were first given an answer to the ... more
Like most people, I get several excellent emails and budget summaries every year and I would guess you do too. ... more
The Insolvency Service produce monthly figures for both corporate and personal insolvencies and to be honest I ... more
If you have been reading our blogs or social media recently you will probably have noticed that we are very busy at ... more
I am already on the third draft of this blog. Every time I managed to get pen to paper the Covid situation or ... more
Over the last few days, a number of extensions have been announced which it is hoped to assist business affected by ... more
There is no such thing as a simple way to close a business. Whether it is an administration or a liquidation, the ... more
Up until the early 2000s HMRC were a preferential creditor in cases of insolvency. When this changed in 2003 it was ... more
The Government has announced that new rules will be brought into legislation as soon as possible. The following was ... more
UPDATED 26 NOVEMBER 2020 The Government has announced extensions to previous temporary measures relating to ... more
There is a potential situation arising that could soon be causing some insolvency related issues, cashflow problems ... more
Insolvency legislation rarely makes the news which is probably why one of the biggest changes to the way it works ... more
This is a very common problem in insolvency and here is the reason why!! At some stage, a director of a new ... more
Why then are we bothering to dedicate a full article and video to cashflow forecasts if they are so common? Well, ... more
The initial shock of the lockdown. When the government announced the Coronavirus lockdown our telephone began to ... more
What happens when you reach out to an Insolvency Practitioner? I doubt any business owner ... more
One of the major aspects of any insolvency is what will happen to the employees. Any news story in relation to an ... more
Find out more about how we can support you when times are tough. We’re here to help with clear, straightforward support.
Call us on 0116 2325117 (Leicester), 01926 671891 (Warwick), 02476017639 (Coventry), 01604 263179 (Northampton) or email us at info@smartbusinessrecovery.co.uk